condensed discuss document expanded export feedback print share remove reset document_white enquire_white export_white report_white

Explore topics

"Wunderpus O Sea", Octavia Cook

discuss document export feedback print share

"Wunderpus O Sea", Octavia Cook

Jane Groufsky
Senior Collection Manager, Human History

The question of intellectual property

Who owns an idea? When does a conventional form become a unique and distinctive design? Auckland Museum recently acquired a brooch by contemporary jeweller Octavia Cook which explores these concepts, and responds to a particular situation in which she found herself in last year.

Since 2001, a recurring motif of Cook’s work has been her youthful self-portrait in cameo form. Her two brooches “O. Cook and J. Cook”, on display in our "Encounters" gallery, pair her own image with the silhouette of James Cook, playing with ideas of significance and sentimentality. “O. Cook and J. Cook” were produced under her invented “Cook & Co.” brand identity, created as a nod to high-end jewellery companies like Tiffany & Co.

\"Wunderpus O Sea\", Octavia Cook, 2017. Acrylic, silver, found object.

"Wunderpus O Sea", Octavia Cook, 2017. Acrylic, silver, found object.

Auckland War Memorial Museum 2017.5.1.

Copyright or convention?

In 2015, Karen Walker began producing a simple cameo ring featuring the profile of a girl with a ponytail in white acrylic on a black background. The ring was based on the company’s “Runaway Girl” motif which was concieved in 2001; a silver pendant version of the Girl silhouette has been a popular mainstay of their jewellery line for over a decade.

Gallerist Anna Miles immediately picked up on the striking similarity between the Karen Walker ring (which retailed for less than $50) and the black and white cameo rings which Cook had been making for some years – specifically, the ponytail which makes Cook’s work so distinctive. Idealog magazine soon published an article in which Karen Walker’s representative refuted the claim, and invited its readers to decide for themselves whether the concerns were legitimate, or a mere coincidence stemming from the use of a historic jewellery convention.

\"Wunderpus O Sea\", Octavia Cook, 2017. Reverse. Acrylic, silver, found object.

"Wunderpus O Sea", Octavia Cook, 2017. Reverse. Acrylic, silver, found object.

Auckland War Memorial Museum 2017.5.1. Reproduced with kind permission of the artist.

A "found object"

Cook has created the brooch “Wunderpus O Sea” as a direct response to this discussion. Her brooch subtly pokes at imitation through its subject: Wunderpus photogenicus is a real species of octopus that resembles the mimic octopus (Thaumoctopus mimicus) which is capable of changing its skin colour and texture to imitate other species.

More overt - but a secret held by the wearer - is the Karen Walker cameo embedded in the reverse of brooch, described by Cook as a “found object”. The title “Wunderpus” is also a nod to the recent landmark contemporary jewellery exhibition “Wunderrūma” (2014, 2015), and the form of the eight-legged octopus echoes Octavia’s name.

Art versus mass production

The Karen Walker cameo ring is not a clear cut case of intellectual property theft, but Cook’s response reflects a global discussion around copyright and the rights of the artist. International companies such as Zara have recently been accused of ripping off the designs of indie artists, relying on corporate might to avoid paying royalties.

Handcrafted works like Cook’s brooch may be made from acrylic and sterling silver, but the prices she commands reflect her many years of experience, her attention to detail, and the artistic rationale behind each piece. It is therefore unsurprising that contemporary jewellers like Cook are fiercely protective of their intellectual property when superficially similar versions can be bought for a fraction of the price. Jewellery like “Wunderpus O Sea” encourages us to think about these stories of artistic identity, handcraft versus mass production, and the blurred lines between fashion, craft and art.

Cite this article

Groufsky, Jane. "Wunderpus O Sea", Octavia Cook. Auckland War Memorial Museum - Tāmaki Paenga Hira. First published: 13 July 2017. Updated: 9 March 2021.

Related objects

print share remove reset export
Displaying 1 - 20 of 14500 records

Discuss this topic

Join the discussion about this article by posting your response on Twitter, Facebook or Instagram using the hashtag #amdiscuss.

Support the collection

Help us do more. Donate now and be part of your Museum’s journey to stimulate inspiration, learning and enjoyment.